Book Reviews

Review — The Evening Chorus by Helen Humphreys

The Evening Chorus by Helen Humphreys. | My copy: ARC, 289 pages, Mariner Books (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt), released February 3rd, 2015. | Source: The publisher via Shelf Awareness. | View on Goodreads here.


Downed during his first mission, James Hunter is taken captive as a German POW. To bide the time, he studies a nest of redstarts at the edge of camp. Some prisoners plot escape; some are shot. And then, one day, James is called to the Kommandant’s office.

Meanwhile, back home, James’s new wife, Rose, is on her own, free in a way she has never known. Then, James’s sister, Enid, loses everything during the Blitz and must seek shelter with Rose. In a cottage near Ashdown forest, the two women jealously guard secrets, but form a surprising friendship. Each of these characters will find unexpected freedom amid war’s privations and discover confinements that come with peace. The Evening Chorus is a beautiful, astonishing examination of love, loss, escape, and the ways in which the intrusions of the natural world can save us.

The review:

The Evening Chorus is a very poignant World War II novel that focuses on three people: James, a prisoner of war, Rose, his young wife, and Enid, his sister. The book goes very slowly; there really isn’t any plot. It’s more about the characters and how they cope during and after the war. The writing, however, is beautiful. I wouldn’t call it simplistic prose, but it’s elegant and doesn’t meander around with too-sweet descriptions or giant, impressive words. The sentences aren’t needlessly long or short. The voice is perfect for the time period. Once I got used to the slow pace I really started focusing on the words. The writing made me enjoy this book a whole lot more.

I liked James and Roses’s story lines a bit more than Enid’s. Enid I didn’t feel as sympathetic toward, even though I did warm up to her. James spends most of the war as a prisoner in a German camp. The way he copes with his terrible predicament is to watch and study the birds that live around the camp. His bird watching even intrigues the Kommandant. James writes home a lot, but only talks of the birds in his letters, which disappoints his young wife Rose — Rose, who has definitely grown out of love with James as their time away passes, and who may never have been truly in love with him. The book, I would say, is really Rose’s story, and how we love a multitude of people in our lives but love them differently. (I really can’t tell you much about Rose’s arc without potential spoilers. But there are two wonderful dogs, Harris and Clementine, who follow Rose around. Who doesn’t love four-legged, furry companions?) And Enid fits into this whole picture when she temporarily moves in with Rose when her London apartment is bombed. Enid has her own problems she’s running from and trying to hide, and it’s interesting seeing how her life changes (or perhaps not?) years after the war is over.

About halfway through The Evening Chorus was when I really started to like it. And after finishing it, I’m very glad I pushed through to the end. I did consider putting this down for a later time, just because it was taking me forever to motivate myself to read. I spent a month on this book, reading a few pages every couple of days until this past week when I made myself sit down and make some considerable progress. It’s not a super-grim, super-sad wartime novel, but it is definitely serious and takes some willpower to read because of its character-driven story, versus plot-driven story. I do recommend The Evening Chorus. It was a very refreshing change from what I’ve been reading lately, and I’m glad I read it, also since a goal of mine is to start reading more Adult fiction. ♦

Have you read The Evening Chorus?
If not, would you want to read it now?
What was the last wartime novel you read?
Comment below letting me know!
And, as always, happy reading!


5 thoughts on “Review — The Evening Chorus by Helen Humphreys

  1. The last wartime novel I read was also a WWII novel: Rose Under Fire by Elizabeth Wein. That one is also pretty character driven, as Wein’s work tends to be. I would say that war books focus on characters often, because everyone knows what happened in the war, but we get to read different people’s perspectives and reactions.


    1. Oh, I need to read Code Name Verity like ASAP… and then the sequel, as well as Elizabeth’s new book, Black Dove White Raven. I’ve read a bunch of wartime novels, and while I agree that a lot of them are character driven, there was at least some suspense in what was going to happen to the characters. With The Evening Chorus everyone felt very sheltered in their own little bubble, if that makes any sense. Even the part with James in the POW camp didn’t make me worry in anticipation. So this book was REALLY just character driven, even though I still ended up liking it.


Got something to say? SPILL!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s